Why we care about copying values between design tools
In almost every plant engineering project we have seen, more time went into transferring values than into calculating. That is why we are building Toolmeyer. This article explains where this finding comes from and what we made of it.
An ordinary Tuesday in plant design
The client changes the district heating flow temperature from 110 to 95 °C. A small change. In the heat balance it is recalculated in ten minutes. Then the real work begins:
- Transfer mass flows and temperatures from the balance program to the process flow diagram.
- Check and adjust the nominal sizes of the affected lines.
- Update the line list, valve list and instrument list.
- Check design pressure and temperature, check the PED classification.
- Set revisions, distribute documents to process engineering, piping and control engineering.
Each step happens in a different program. Each step is a chance to copy a number wrongly or forget it.
What it costs
The following estimate is based on our project experience, not on a study. It shows the order of magnitude for a medium-sized plant with around 150 lines.
| Work step for one change | separate tools | one data model |
|---|---|---|
| Recalculate the balance | 0.5 h | 0.5 h |
| Transfer values to the flow diagram | 2–4 h | automatic |
| Update the lists | 4–8 h | automatic, check 1 h |
| Coordination between disciplines | 2–4 h | 1 h |
| Tracking down inconsistencies | hard to plan | largely eliminated |
With ten such changes in a project, that quickly adds up to 80 to 150 hours of pure transfer work.
Why there are so many tools
The tools are not bad. Each is built for one task: simulation programs for thermodynamics, CAD for drawings, database systems for large corporations, Excel for everything in between. People fill the gaps between them. Large companies have whole departments for this. In engineering consultancies and mid-sized plant builders, the project engineer does it on the side.
What we made of it
Toolmeyer keeps all design data in one model. The heat balance diagram is the source. Process flow diagram, P&ID and lists are views of it. Three rules have proven important:
- Changes flow in one direction only: from the diagram to the flow diagram to the lists, never back.
- Manual work is never overwritten: anyone who has moved a valve in the flow diagram or set a value by hand keeps it.
- Every change is shown before it is applied: the engineer decides, not the program.
Why now
AI assistants can answer technical questions surprisingly well today. But they do not solve the transfer problem. A text answer is not a checked balance and not a revised list. What engineers need is a tool in which the numbers are right in one place and appear the same everywhere. AI can operate this tool, but it cannot replace it.
What we would like from readers
If you know the same friction in your projects, try Toolmeyer with a plant of your own. Tell us on the feedback page where it gets stuck. Most features in Toolmeyer came from exactly this kind of feedback.
Disclosure: the author is part of the team that develops and sells Toolmeyer.